When Jam Circles Become Stages, What Do We Lose?

When Circles Become Stages

We hear this sometimes: “I’m not good enough.” “It feels like a VIP zone for rockstars.” “People will judge.”

This fear is a symptom.

It tells us the Jam Circle has shifted from a container to a stage. In many scenes, the center becomes a spotlight, and the dance becomes a test. It tells us the circle is holding its breath, waiting for “perfection” instead of connection.

We stop looking at each other, and start looking for approval. The question shifts from “How do we share?” to “Am I good enough to be seen?”

But historically, a stage separates us. A circle connects us.

Built for Survival

In African American traditions, circles did not just originate during enslavement, but evolved and adapted from African traditions, carrying forward deep cultural and communal meanings, and continued to emerge within communities living under racism and structural violence. Music and dance were social glue, emotional release, and survival tools.

As Frantz Fanon described:

“The circle of the dance is a permissive circle: it protects and permits… It is a tool for survival.”

Outside the circle, you might be dehumanized. Inside, you were fully human. The circle wasn’t a stage to rank who was best. It was a place where the community was protected and held together.

Energy Must Move

At the 2024 Good Time Blues Festival, musician Noreda Graves reminded us that holding back isn’t humility—it’s selfishness. It means we are willing to consume the energy of the room, but unwilling to contribute to it.

Think of the circle like a fire. If everyone warms their hands but no one adds wood, the fire dies.

If energy only comes in (watching) and never flows out (dancing), the circle slowly loses its life. It’s not about skill; it’s about keeping the fire burning.

Historically, participation wasn’t about being “ready.” If you could clap, you clapped. If you could move, you moved.

You didn’t enter because you had a prepared routine. You entered because your presence mattered. A mistake shared with a laugh creates more connection than a perfect move performed with coldness.

Skill was not the gate. Participation was the pulse.

Different Levels, Same Circle

In Black social dance spaces, the floor was shared by everyone: Beginners, elders, children, and masters—together. The “village” was never segregated by dance ability.

People learned by watching, copying, failing, and being welcomed back in. Growth happened through circulation (being part of the mix), not selection (being the best in the room). You didn’t graduate to the circle; you were born into it.

The One Who Sustains

Jacqui Malone, in Steppin’ on the Blues, offers a powerful definition of a “good dancer”:

“…the good dancer does not go outside the mode established by the supporting group.”

An advanced dancer isn’t just someone who shines. They are someone who brings their power to renew the group’s value. They use their skill to open the door for others, not to close it. One shines. The other sustains.

Groove Over Proving

Feeling you have “nothing to show” is a trap. Entering the circle doesn’t require complex variations.

It invites us to slow down, listen, and settle into the groove. The deepest conversations don’t always need big words. Simple movement is not wasted music. It is a return to the roots of the dance. A basic step, done with heart, connects deeper than a flashy move done with anxiety.

Culture, Choice, and Care

This doesn’t mean you must force yourself in when you feel unsafe or exhausted. Boundaries and consent always matter.

The goal isn’t “always say yes.” The goal is to shift the question we ask ourselves:

From: “Will I look good?”
To: “How can I help the energy flow?”

Sometimes that means dancing. Sometimes that means shouting, clapping, and hyping up the person next to you. Every bit of energy counts.

Keep It Breathing

We are still learning. But listening to these traditions invites a simple shift: If jam circles become places of fear, the dance has gone quiet. If they remain places of sharing, the culture stays alive.

Next time, ask yourself: “What energy can I offer this circle today?”

Even a small groove is a gift. Even a simple step is circulation.

(Save & Share to help us change the culture of our circles 💛)